Joseph Eisenberg
Born: 1875, Mizheric, near Vilna, Eastern Europe (Lithuania or Ukraine?)
Died: January 23, 1941, Brooklyn, NY
Relation to Author: Great Grandfather-in-Law
The NY Times had an article a little while ago about the return of the Cossacks. To me the interesting part of the story isn’t the scary ultra-nationalism hiding behind a thin vale of pride in their heritage. Instead, I was more interested in the history of the Cossacks as described in the article - especially because it is a much more helpful history than I had found on Wikipedia.
The history of the Cossacks is important to our genealogy research because the oral history of the Eisenberg family says Joseph was in a Cossack army. This new article could help us with our mystery about where Joseph and his family were from.
In the article, it looks like the Cossacks were mostly in Southern Russia. This would put them, and therefore maybe Joseph, closer to Ukraine. So this puts doubt into the Lituania thesis.
This whole discussion though about Joseph Eisenberg's origins brings up two interesting points. First, it sheds some light on the reliability of oral histories. Any oral or written history should be taken with a grain of salt, especially third person (here Meyer is writing about his father's experiences). However, sometimes these oral histories are the only information we have.
The second point this discussion highlights is the existence of mysteries in genealogical research. To be sure, I am quite the novice when it comes to actual genealogical research. So hopefully with time and experience, I can figure this out. I might find out that the assumption everyone has been holding all along is true - that Joseph is in fact from Ukraine. Although hopefully I'll be able to put a thumbtack on a map with an actual location - which has been my goal all along. But I might not. This might remain a bit of a mystery.
No comments:
Post a Comment